Stealth Action Game Compilation Review: Metal Gear Solid Master Collection Vol. 1

Metal Gear Solid Master Collection Vol. 1 is the latest in a long line of compilations featuring Metal Gear games. It made its own name, however, by having several things going for it that no other compilation before it had.

The first volume of the Master Collection is headlined by the first three Metal Gear Solid games, but it actually contains seven games and two variants. The games that have appeared in other compilations over the years include the console versions of the mobile remakes of the MSX2 versions of Metal Gear and Metal Gear 2: Solid Snake, Metal Gear Solid, Metal Gear Solid: VR Missions, Metal Gear Solid 2: Sons of Liberty, and Metal Gear Solid 3: Snake Eater.

Beyond these games, the compilation also saw the first re-release of the Family Computer and Nintendo Entertainment System version of Metal Gear and the NES-exclusive sequel Snake's Revenge. It also was the first international release of Metal Gear Solid: Integral, which was originally released only in Japan. This game combined the international version of Metal Gear Solid, with the English voices and the choice of Japanese or English subtitles with the VR Missions. Integral was actually the original release of the latter before it was released in North America as Metal Gear Solid: VR Missions and in Europe as Metal Gear Solid: Special Missions.

Beyond the included games, the Master Collection also includes the motion comics Metal Gear Solid: Digital Graphic Novel, which digitized IDW Publishing's graphic novel adaptation of Metal Gear Solid  and Metal Gear Solid 2: Bande Dessinée, which digitized IDW Publishing's graphic novel adaptation of Metal Gear Solid: Sons of Liberty.

Metal Gear Solid Master Collection Vol. 1 is a large treasure trove of Metal Gear games that were released throughout three decades. However, its value will largely come down to whether you don't own another Metal Gear Solid compilation and whether the compilation-exclusive games such as the NES version of Metal Gear and Snake's Revenge as well as the first international release of Metal Gear Solid: Integral matter to you. If either of those cases turn out to be yes for you, then this compilation is well worth picking up.

Final Verdict:

4½ out of 5

Action Stealth Game Review: Metal Gear 2 - Solid Snake

While it was the giant success that Metal Gear Solid would become upon its release over ten years after the start of the series, the original Metal Gear was enough of a success that two sequels from two separate teams were put into production. 

The Ultra Games version of Metal Gear received the Nintendo Entertainment System exclusive Snake's Revenge in Europe and North America. This sequel led series creator Hideo Kojima to put Metal Gear 2: Solid Snake into production for MSX2. Unlike the original MSX2 version of Metal Gear, which received an official English version in Europe, Solid Snake was only released in Japan. This led to somewhat of a mythical release, as Metal Gear 2 was only available via a fan translation until an English version of the mobile remake was included in Metal Gear Solid 3: Subsistence in 2006.

The gameplay retained the stealth action gameplay of the original game, but it introduced several concepts that would remain part of the series going forward. including crawling, and crouching. There was also more danger which could be spotted with the radar. Enemies now respond to sound produced by Snake such as footsteps. To avoid being spotted, Snake now can hide under tables or inside lockers.

The graphics of Metal Gear 2 for MSX2 were very similar to those of the original MSX2 version of the first game. This meant that they were in a classic overhead style with characters and locations being as well-detailed as 8-bit graphics allowed. The music and sound effects, likewise, also fit in the game well.

Hideo Kojima is a fan of American action films, which shows in his game design as well as in the design of the detailed character portraits in Metal Gear 2: Solid Snake. Some obvious ones include Mel Gibson as Solid Snake and Sean Connery as Big Boss. Other character portraits include Platoon's Tom Berenger as Grey Fox was based on Tom Berenger in Platoon, Rambo's Richard Crenna as Roy Campbell, and Gunhed's Brenda Bakke as Holly White.

Metal Gear 2: Solid Snake was a huge step forward for the series. The new elements were a necessary evolution which would be included in all of the games moving forward. The radar, enemies hearing sounds of footsteps, and the ability to hide in lockers, would become a huge part of Metal Gear Solid when it released eight years later.

Final Verdict:

4 out of 5

Metal Gear (Ultra Games) Review

Metal Gear Solid Review

Action Stealth Game Review: Metal Gear Solid 2: Sons of Liberty

Metal Gear Solid 2: Sons of Liberty was the highly anticipated sequel to the highly successful and influential action-adventure stealth game, Metal Gear Solid. While the series had several games before Solid, it was that game that put the series on the map, and it was that game that Hideo Kojima and his team at Konami had to follow.

Sons of Liberty did not disappoint. The music is just as great as its predecessor, as is the sound effects such as footsteps and the clinks and clanks of the mostly metal environment. The biggest gain is when it came to improving upon the technical aspects of the game compared to its predecessor.  The increase in capability from the PlayStation to the PlayStation 2 was a huge leap. This allowed the team to give the characters full facial expressions, which was a much-needed upgrade from the creepy eye-less visage of Solid Snake from the PlayStation game.

With the graphics increase also came a more detailed game world, and new abilities. Solid Snake can now use first-person aiming beyond the sniper rifle. The original Solid had an auto-aiming feature, which, while effective, is not as effective as true first-person aiming. Even aiming with the sniper rifle is improved, as Metal Gear Solid felt stiff when in first-person mode for this item, whereas Sons of Liberty feels much smoother.

Snake is also more acrobatic now, with rolls and leaps in addition to climbing and hanging. I've been mentioning Snake, but, as is common knowledge by now, Kojima pulled a bait-and-switch by replacing the main character for most of the game.

After the first chapter of the game, which features Solid Snake as the main character, the rest of the game has a new main character in Raiden. Raiden, also known as Jack, is wildly different from Snake. Whereas Snake is the poster boy for the stoic hero, Raiden is much more emotional. His body type is also much more lean and androgenous as opposed to Snake's action movie hero physique.

This caused a lot of controversy when the game was released, but that has largely died down in the intervening years, especially after Raiden was more fleshed out in his next outing as protagonist in Metal Gear Rising. Raiden is actually a fine protagonist, and is actually more acrobatic than Snake, which makes playing the game feel a bit smoother compared to the intro with Solid Snake.

The other controversy, which is kind of laughable now with how weird the series became in later years, is the weirdness of the game's story. Beyond the usual weirdness inherent in the series as a whole, this chapter added in a whole lot of strangeness in the form of artificial intelligence, which actually makes the game more prescient in the current era.

Metal Gear Solid 2: Sons of Liberty is a fantastic sequel to the seminal classic Metal Gear Solid. The increase in graphical fidelity and the increased smoothness of the controls made it feel so much better. The story is a bit weirder than its predecessor, and the swap of protagonists still has its detractors, but these changes actually fleshed out the game world. It's a fine installment of a fantastic series, and is still worth playing today.

Final Verdict:

4½ out of 5

Metal Gear Solid Review

Metal Gear Solid 3 Review Coming Soon

Stealth Action Game Review: Metal Gear Solid

Metal Gear Solid was not only the first Metal Gear game after an eight year hiatus, it was also the first fully three-dimensional game in the series. Released for the PlayStation in 1998, it propelled the series and its creator into worldwide fame.

Hideo Kojima was always a fan of Western action media, as evidenced by the use of stars from American action movies as the basis of the character portraits in the original Metal Gear 2: Solid Snake on the MSX2. Heck, even the name Snake comes from the main protagonist in Escape from New York.  

Thus, it made sense that once gaming moved into the true third dimension with the release of the 32-bit and 64-bit consoles, Kojima would attempt to emulate his favorite films cinematically as well. Kojima has become infamous for the use of long cutscenes in his games, but in the original Metal Gear Solid, they are undoubtedly a benefit to the game, making the game feel more engrossing while not feeling like a slog. Heck, even the remade cinematics in Metal Gear Solid: The Twin Snakes for GameCube, goofy as they are, still manage to come in at a runtime that doesn't infringe upon the enjoyment of the gameplay.

Solid Snake is sent to Alaska, where he needs to do what he does best. He must infiltrate an enemy base and stop a Metal Gear, this time the model known as REX. He is first sent to rescue the DARPA chief and discovers a conspiracy to which he was clearly not previously privy. At this point, he also meets a fan-favorite character known as Meryl Silverburgh, the biological daughter of Snake's mission leader Colonel Campbell.

Snake also has help from people on his codec, as usual for this series. Snake simply has to communicate because the codec is implanted in him. Along with Campbell, Snake communicates with Mei Long who saves his mission data and offers philosophical quotes, Master Miller who offers non-sequiturs and occasional advice, and eventually series regular Dr. Emmerich aka Otacon who offers information about the base and Metal Gear REX itself.

The story is one of the best, if not the best, of the Hideo Kojima stories. There are so many twists and turns in the story, and the characters are really interesting. It leaves a lasting impression. The voice work of the actors is fantastic, both in the English and Japanese language. If you have played through Metal Gear Solid in English, you could find it fun to play it again with the Japanese voice actors in the Metal Gear Solid: Master Collection, assuming you don't mind reading the English subtitles if you don't mind Japanese.

The music is fantastic too. Unless you play at the easiest level, or are fantastic at playing action stealth games, you'll likely see the game over screen at least once. This has become iconic for a reason. The voice over that accompanies it is fantastic and the game over music is extremely memorable. Of course, the rest of the music is fantastic as well, but that was epic enough it deserved a write-up on its own. The sound effects are also great, giving the game its polished feel.

The stealth gameplay was influential on the genre, and even though a lot has changed in the nearly twenty years since its 1998 release, it is still great to play today. The Metal Gear Solid: The Twin Snakes remake adds some then-modern touches. It does make the game feel different because the first person mode makes some parts easier than the original. If the PlayStation version of Metal Gear Solid feels stiff to you, and you don't mind some goofy cutscene changes, that might be an option. The earlier Metal Gear Solid: Integral also includes first person mode, which might be a better option since its gaming and presentation comes from the North American release of the original Metal Gear Solid PlayStation release.

For those really willing to dig deep into the history of video gaming and emulation, there is bleemcast! for Metal Gear Solid for the Dreamcast. Playing the game using this will make the game smoother. It's true that most PlayStation emulators will have an option for smoothing, but the bleemcast! experience is surprisingly smooth, and it's amazing to experience considering the PlayStation and Dreamcast were direct competitors that were only one console generation apart.

Metal Gear Solid is well worth playing, in any form, from the original PlayStation version on the PlayStation console or on emulators to the GameCube Metal Gear Solid: Twin Snakes remake. I recommend the PlayStation version on console or emulator, since the cutscenes are 2000s action film level goofy in the remake. Some of the original cutscenes can be goofy too, but it is worth it to play it in its original form. If you have played the original, and especially if you have played it many times, it could be worth it to play the PlayStation version with Japanese voice actors and English subtitles to experience the Japanese voice actors. The actors in the Japanese version are just as high-quality as those in the English version. It could also be worth it to play Metal Gear Solid: Integral, if you want to experience the game with first person mode. If you don't mind cutscene changes that make the game feel like a goofy late 1990s to early 2000s American action film, Metal Gear Solid: Twin Snakes might also be worth experiencing. No matter which version you play, the stealth gameplay, excellent voice acting, plus fantastic music and sound effects make this one a classic that every video gamer should experience at least once.

Final Verdict:
5 out of 5

Metal Gear 2: Solid Snake Review

Metal Gear Solid 2: Sons of Liberty Review

Stealth Action Game Mega Review: Metal Gear for C64, DOS, and NES

Metal Gear for the Nintendo Entertainment System is a very different game than the original MSX2 game of the same name. It, along with the lesser known Commodore 64 and DOS ports, has become something of a red-headed stepchild as it was both created without the input of series creator Hideo Kojima and suffered from meddling when the management at Konami requested that it be as different as possible from the original. It gets a lot of flack for those reasons, but it really isn't a bad game, especially considering the constraints of its development. 

The game has the same general set up as the MSX2 Metal Gear. Solid Snake has to infiltrate an enemy encampment and has backup off-site through radio contact such as with his mission commander, Big Boss. The primary difference here is that the mission takes place in an outdoor military encampment whereas the original took place inside a sprawling enemy base. This makes it have more in common with Metal Gear Solid 3: Snake Eater than the original Metal Gear Solid, which took direct inspiration from the MSX2 Metal Gear games.

The comparison is superficial however, as Kojima has stated his dislike of the NES Metal Gear games. This is unfair however, as the game is quite fun on its own. I did play it often on my toaster NES when I was a little girl, so I'll admit some of my like of the game may be rose-colored glasses. However, even when I replayed it recently on the Metal Gear Solid Collection: Vol. 1 for the Nintendo Switch, I still had a lot of fun with it.

The game has the oft-mentioned poor English translations such as "I feel asleep". It also doesn't have as strong of a story as the original, although even the MSX2 version doesn't have the context-heavy radio calls for which the series would become known. The game also doesn't have the titular final boss. Due to hardware restraints of the NES and the limitations of the mapper used, Solid Snake a giant super computer instead of a Metal Gear mech.

The Nintendo Entertainment System version of Metal Gear is still fun to play, if you are open to playing top-down two-dimensional 8-bit action stealth games. With its outdoor locales, you may have fun with this game even if you played the MSX2 game or its console remake. The limitations of the console even work out for making it a different experience due to the very different final boss. It is not as good of a game as the MSX2 original, but in my opinion it comes really close.

Final Verdict:
3 out of 5

Metal Gear Review

Metal Gear 2: Solid Snake Review

Stealth Action Game Review: Metal Gear

Metal Gear for the MSX2 computer is a very different beast from the Nintendo Entertainment System version that international players received. It is also the version that connects to the later games, as the two NES games are ignored by the storylines of the Metal Gear Solid games. The full three-dimensional third-person presentation of the latter made it a bonafide worldwide hit. However, even in the top-down perspective of the original game, many of the stealth mechanics that made Solid so popular were already present.

Metal Gear was released in for MSX2 in 1987 as the first game in the eponymous series. It was released in Japan and Europe, but the latter received a truncated version of the game with nearly half as many radio transmissions and truncated messages. 

A faithful remake of the original version was developed in the J2ME subset of Java and released for feature phones in Japan in 2004. It included an easy mode with a bandanna that gave infinite ammunition, larger text, and end-of-game statistics and related player codenames. This version was the basis of the version that was released worldwide in 2005 as a bonus on Metal Gear Solid 3: Subsistence.

Solid Snake begins his mission in much the same manner as he would later in Metal Gear Solid. Snake travels through the water to infiltrate an enemy base and receives a transmission from his mission commander who is known by the codename Big Boss. As the game progresses, Snake will be able to make and receive radio transmissions from other characters as well.

Snake finds keycards throughout the game, which can be used to unlock doors. In these doors, he may find weapons and gadgets to help him in his mission. He can also go into the back of trucks to find items to use, but sometimes enemy guards will be found instead. Snake can punch these guards or use the weapons he found. He can also use rations to refill his health bar.

There are two storage compartments where Snake keeps his items. The first stores items such as keycards and rations, while the second stores weapons. These can be set as active at all times. This allows Snake to enter doors with a keycard without having to manually activate the keycard. It also sets the weapon, which lets Snake fire it while it is active. This is especially helpful with rations, as Snake's health will be automatically refilled to an extent when it reaches zero.

The rations help a lot with the boss battles. There are no memorable bosses as in the Solid series. You won't find Psycho Mantis-style originality here, but the bosses do offer some variety as Snake battles terrifying gun-wielding soldiers and huge mobile weapons. The latter gives the player the first taste of the nuclear-loaded mecha known as Metal Gear.

Metal Gear is not as welcoming as its Solid brethren, but it does offer fun stealth action to those who are open to 8-bit game mechanics. With many of the game mechanics the Metal Gear Solid games would become known for, this is a fascinating game to play to see how the series started, if nothing else. It is also very easy to come by as the 2005 remake version has been ported to most consoles as well as Windows since that came out since it was first released. 

Final Verdict:
3½ out of 5

Metal Gear (Ultra Games) Review