Sunday, October 18, 2015

Choices-and-Consequences Game Review: Game of Thrones Episode 2

Saturday, October 17, 2015

Choices-and-Consequences Game Review: Game of Thrones Episode 1

Telltale has managed to score another popular franchise with Game of Thrones.  This series is all about bloodlines and betrayals, so it seems like the perfect fit with the choices and consequences model that Telltale has used for all of their games since The Walking Dead: Season One.

The game follows the noble house of Forrester, a clan that provides the realm with strong equipment made from Ironwood trees.  The Forrester clan has only been mentioned in passing in the novels on which HBO's Game of Thrones is based.  This gives Telltale a lot of freedom to make their own characters, while still making it fit right within the continuity of the Game of Thrones world.

Like 400 Days before it, this game has several different protagonists, and their stories will weave in and out of each other as the episodes unfold.  Game of Thrones is told in six episodes, so this format should serve this game much better than its predecessor, as even though the story was interesting enough, one episode was not enough time to get to know each of the protagonists.

The game opens with the death of the head of the house Forrester, and each member of the house, from the family members, to the loyal servants, must make choices to try to keep the house going in their leader's stead.  As with all of Telltale's choices and consequences games so far, this episode doesn't reveal too many consequences yet, but it does seem that this format could lead to a good deal of consequences down the road, especially as each protagonist makes their own choices.

Choices are hard to make in the Game of Thrones world, as good people usually do not live long, so it should be interesting to see what follows.  There is a good chance that the game will enter even murkier waters than the morally challenged protagonists from Tales from the Borderlands.

The game is presented in an interesting art style that resembles a painting, with heavy brush strokes apparent on the backgrounds, but it's especially apparent on the characters.  It takes a bit of getting used to, but it's actually quite pleasant once you do, especially in the backgrounds.  The eyes of the characters have a bit of an uncanny-valley quality, however, but it's not too distracting.

The music and voice acting is always top notch in Telltale's games and it definitely shines here.  The music uses the soundtrack from the television show mixed with an original score.  The licensed music makes the game feel like it's part of the Game of Thrones show, while the original score fits the tone of each of the scenes wonderfully.  The voice cast is fantastic as well.  Each of the protagonists are voiced excellently, and they are joined by some of the cast from the HBO show as well.  As with Telltale's CSI games, some of the actors from the show sound more wooden than others, but they all work well, and add to the authenticity of the game.

Outside of the choices and consequences, the rest of the game is presented in quick time events. Telltale does need to mix things up a bit, as the QTE's are becoming Telltale's go-to game play device, and they're getting a bit tiresome at this point.  It's a shame there's no puzzles or at least some direct control action sections, as the direct controlled action from the middle of the first season of The Walking Dead would have really worked well here.

The first episode of Game of Thrones manages to be an exciting premiere episode, story-wise.  The finale is one of the most memorable moments I've seen in a Telltale game so far.  It's something that Telltale hasn't tried before, and is certainly quite the cliff-hanger for what's to come.  The music and voice acting is also top notch, matching the excellent standards set by the story.  The painting-like art style is a bit jarring at first, but works well once you get used to it.  The game play however, is a bit lacking.  The choices and consequences do seem like they could be used quite well in the setting of Game of Thrones, but most of the consequences from the choices made in this episode will come later in the season.  The rest of the game play consists of quick time events, which is a shame as Telltale has shown that they're capable of more compelling gameplay with the puzzle based or direct action based gameplay in some of their other seasons.  The latter could have definitely been used well in the Game of Thrones setting.  Even with it's shortcomings, however, the excellent story and presentation make Iron From Ice an intriguing start to the season.

Final Verdict:

4 out of 5

Friday, October 16, 2015

Choices-and-Consequences Game Review: Tales from the Borderlands Episode 4

Tales from the Borderlands keeps up the strong momentum set by previous episodes in episode four, which ends up being another strong installment in this entertaining series.

The best part of the game from a gameplay standpoint has been the extras that Telltale has added for this series.  The bionic eye is used well as always, giving excellent information to those who use it on objects, and funny lines to those who had opted to trust Jack earlier.  It's not used in puzzles as much in this episode, which is a shame, but it's still a fun addition that is good to have.

The story is where Telltale always shines, and this is the strongest of the series so far.  Telltale's writers love to tickle your funny bone in their humorous games, and they do so here, in spades.  They have the best opening of the series yet, with some of the funniest moments of the series so far, once again set against music that sets the tone beautifully.  Jack gets some nice one-liners in, of course, and Gortys is wonderfully naiive as always.  There is also an over-the-top action sequence, that harkens back to the first episode.  It's heavy in quick-time-events, but, for the scene, it works.

Even Telltale's humorous games tend to get grounded at times, and pull at your heart strings as well. This episode has perhaps the most moving moment of the entire series.  By the end of the sequence I found myself in tears, which is saying something, as Telltale managed to make me care about a character that I for whom I previously didn't care anything.  The ending sequence also had some excellent dramatic moments, and set up a fantastic cliffhanger for the finale.

The penultimate episode of Tales from the Borderlands is the best yet.  It has fantastic music and the actors perform their lines wonderfully.  The bionic eye is still used to great effect when examining objects.  The best part about the episode is the story, which delivers equal amounts of humor and drama.  The tension rises at the end of the episode, and leaves things on an exciting cliff-hanger. This season has been exciting and entertaining so far.  If the last episode lives up to expectations, this series could potentially be one of the best cinematic choice and consequences game they have produced so far.

Final verdict:

4½ out of 5
Episode Three ReviewEpisode Five Review

Thursday, October 15, 2015

Choices-and-Consequences Game Review: Tales from the Borderlands Episode 3

The third episode of Tales from the Borderlands keeps the ball running, with a fantastic chapter that keeps the momentum set by the excellent chapters that came before it.

The episode begins as the duo find themselves in danger.  There are more people who want the full power of the Gortys project, and Rhys and Fiona are their way to get what they want.  The series begins to take an interesting turn depending on your choice of who to side with, and the designers have fun with that choice.  The bionic eye of Rhys has always been a nice addition to the game, being both useful to game play, as well as bringing back the look function in a new way.  It's even more fun now. If you choose to side with Jack, the optic output of the eye implant of Rhys displays sarcastic information about an object you scanned instead of the regular information feed from Hyperion.

The voice cast once again shines, but the breakout of this episode is the voice actress of Gortys.  Her character is written with a simple, cute charm, and her voice is a big part of that.  Her interactions with Loaderbot are the highlight of this chapter.  The music once again continues to shine right alongside the excellent voice work, especially the title song.  The opening sequences in this series have been a delight since the beginning, and that trend continues in full force here.

The third chapter of Tales from the Borderlands feels a bit short. It more than makes up for it with an excellent narrative with branches from choices that are beginning to have a noticeable effect on the story line,   Both new and returning characters are excellently voiced, their interactions are memorable, and the music frames the story and blends in with the excellent voice work seamlessly. If the story continues on this path, Rhys and Fiona are truly destined for greatness.

Final verdict:

4 out of 5
Episode Two ReviewEpisode Four Review

Wednesday, October 14, 2015

Point and Click Adventure Review: Space Quest V

Space Quest V was a departure from the previous games in many ways.  It was the first game in the series to not be helmed by both creators of the franchise, It was also the first to be developed by a developer other than Sierra, as it was developed by Sierra's Dynamix division.  It also found Roger in a position of power for the first time.  However, despite these changes, or possibly because of them, Space Quest V is one of the best games in the series.

Roger Wilco cheats on his test at Starcon Academy and finds himself as captain of the SCS Eureka, a ship designed to vacuum space debris. He's technically still a janitor but now finds that he's no longer the lowest member of his assigned spacecraft. For the first time, he has power over the members of his crew, even if they aren't particularly enthralled to be assigned to a garbage scow. His simple mission soon gets complicated, as he finds himself in the middle of a toxic conspiracy.

This game doesn't have voice acting, despite the fact that there is voice acting in the two games that bookmark it.  Thankfully, the writing more than makes up for it, as the humor in this game is top-notch.  The previous game had a lot of funny moments, but this game breaks out all the puns and references to Star Trek and other science fiction juggernauts that it can. Thankfully, the humor isn't overbearing on the main plot, as it is rock solid here.  Roger really shines in a leadership position, and the villain that he faces is excellent and quite multifaceted.

The art style is fantastic for its time, which was always one of the strong points of Sierra, and its associated divisions.  The backgrounds have a lot of detail, and the animation of the sprites is great. The puzzles in this game are quite difficult, as is usual in Sierra's games.  Thankfully, there aren't any puzzles that don't make sense logically.  Some stretch real-world logic a bit, but within the context of the game's science fiction world, they fit in fine.  This game is definitely one of those that fit in the Sierra mantra of save early, save often.  It is very possible to die, especially in confrontations with enemies, so it would be wise to save whenever you make progress.  It's also possible to get in a dead end, and some sequences require precise timing, which can be quite infuriating at times. This player-punishing style of Sierra's games didn't age as well as their contemporaries at LucasArts, but if you're willing to play through despite the frustration, the underlying story is worth experiencing.

Final Verdict:

3½ out of 5

Tuesday, October 13, 2015

Choices-and-Consequences Game Review: Minecraft: Story Mode Episode 1

Minecraft: Story Mode seemed like a really odd choice for a franchise for Telltale to tackle.  The original Minecraft game was a sandbox construction game, without a story of its own, and little lore outside of the characters and enemies from the game.  Surprisingly, Telltale manages to deliver a great experience with the license, even going as far as adding in elements that their other choices and consequences games lack.

It continues the modern Telltale formula in a good way. It has an interesting story about a beast that is unleashed, and the game's group has to track down people who can help stop it. It has choices in the dialog, with consequences that come in the form of characters changing their opinion on you based on what you choose. Plus, there are choices to make on which character to save. It expands on the idea introduced in The Wolf Among Us of choosing one path, and the other one plays out whether you are there or not. Except this time, it feels like the choice matters more, as it extends into the next episode rather than being contained in a single chapter.

The new mechanics are where the game really shines. This is Telltale's first game to have customizable characters, including gender. Male and female Jesse have the same lines, but the actors read the lines really differently, so going through for a second playthrough really is worthwhile to hear those subtle differences.  The rest of the voice cast is excellent as well, delivering performances to equal the great standard set by the voice actors for the main character.  The music is excellent as well, with an electronic style of soundtrack that really fits the tone of the game.

There's two areas of exploration here where you can just stop and look around and interact with objects and characters. The first one doesn't have a lot of character interaction though, but it's definitely good to see more areas that allow you to explore, without being led on rails through cutscenes and quick time events. Speaking of quick time events, there aren't as many of them here, which is my absolute favorite part of the game. The direct controlled action with a hit counter really shines. It's miles better than quick time events, and I really hope it becomes the standard for Telltale's action scenes from here on out.

The Minecraft art style is mimicked, but not duplicated.  The characters are still blocky, but they are presented in a style that is much more pleasing aesthetic that fits the high resolution cinematic presentation that are the cornerstone of Telltale's modern games. The game also mimics the Minecraft style of gameplay through the crafting table, which lets you collect items to craft. These items are sometimes used to craft weapons, as expected, but they can also be used to craft items for use in getting out of situations (and the item you can craft depends on the items you collect in your inventory). I was also pleasantly surprised to see the return of real puzzles, in the form of a switch puzzle at the end of the episode.

Minecraft: Story Mode succeeds in spades in melding the Telltale style with the Minecraft universe.  The Minecraft style is mimicked, albeit in a more visually pleasing fashion.  The crafting table is used to great extent as well, making good use of the inventory system.   The voice acting and music is top notch, and the choices and consequences style of gameplay is integrated into the Minecraft universe well.  Best of all, Telltale is finally evolving their gameplay here, with direct control combat rather than relying on quick time events for action scenes.  This is the most adventure style of game that Telltale has created in a long time, as there is also a switch puzzle near the end of the game. Minecraft: Story Mode is a nice blend of old Telltale with new Telltale, mixed in with mechanics that never have been in a Telltale game before.

Final Verdict:

4½ out of 5

Minecraft Episode 1 and Back to the Future Remaster Out Now

The first episode of Telltale's Minecraft: Story Mode is available today.  On top of that, Back to the Future: The Game - 30th Anniversary Edition, the remaster of the game with improved textures and Tom Wilson as Biff, has been released as well.

Clearing up a few misconceptions about the game from early press about the remaster, Tom Wilson only plays Biff Tannen.  Owen Thomas still plays Kid Tannen and Beauregard Tannen, and Andrew Chaikin still plays Cliff and Riff.